Skip to main content

The Selective Silence of an Educated Society


We live in an age where people are extremely informed. They follow international politics, discuss democracy, debate economics, write about human rights and express opinions on almost everything.


Yet, when it comes to discrimination, injustice or atrocities against Muslims in India, many suddenly struggle to understand the conversation.


Is it a lack of information, or simply a lack of empathy?


Consider this newspaper report. A woman who had been presumed murdered resurfaced alive after years. A man accused in connection with her disappearance had already spent nearly two and a half years in jail. The investigation now has to be revisited.


It is a reminder of how devastating an accusation can become when investigation, policing and justice fail.


But this should also make us reflect on something much larger.


What about those who spend years in prison, sometimes more than a decade, before being acquitted or released because the prosecution fails to establish its case? What about their lost careers, families, dignity and the years that can never be returned?


This is not an argument against investigating crimes or seeking justice for victims. It is an argument for equal standards of justice, regardless of religion, identity or political convenience.


The numbers deserve attention too:


- According to NCRB prison statistics for 2024, Muslims accounted for approximately 18.8% of undertrial prisoners, despite constituting around 14.2% of India's population.

- India had more than 3.7 lakh undertrial prisoners. Nearly 73% of the prison population consisted of people whose cases were still awaiting a final judicial outcome.

- India Hate Lab documented 1,318 hate-speech events targeting religious minorities in 2025, 98% of which targeted Muslims, either exclusively or alongside Christians.


These figures come from different sources and measure different things, but together they raise serious questions about equality, prejudice and institutional accountability.


And yet, the most disturbing part is sometimes not the injustice itself, but the response to it.


Educated and privileged people are not necessarily unaware. They have access to information, international perspectives and platforms to express themselves. But when uncomfortable realities challenge their political, religious or social preferences, they often change the subject, demand impossible standards of evidence, dismiss the concern or simply pretend not to understand.


Silence is not always neutrality. Sometimes it is the comfort of privilege.


We cannot selectively defend human rights, constitutional values and democracy. They cannot depend on the identity of the victim or the political convenience of the moment.


A society is not measured by how passionately its privileged people speak about justice when it concerns others, but by whether they can recognise injustice when it happens to those they have been conditioned not to empathise with.


Perhaps we are not short of educated people or information.


We are falling short of our humanitarian responsibility.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Marketplace of Lonely Hearts

The same story all men have! There was a time when he believed technology had made the world kinder. Every face was only a swipe away. Every conversation began with hope. Every notification carried the possibility of friendship, love, or simply someone who would ask, "How was your day?" But he entered that world not when he was strong. He entered when life had already broken him. ... He wasn't looking for perfection. He wasn't searching for beauty. He wasn't even chasing romance. He was searching for a human voice. Someone to talk to after job. Someone who would understand silence without asking questions. Instead, he found algorithms. Every swipe rewarded hope. Every message triggered anticipation. Every delayed reply created anxiety. Every notification became a tiny dose of dopamine. The platforms called it engagement. He slowly realized it was addiction. ... The women he met often had heartbreaking stories. A sick mother. An unpaid rent. A lost job. A stranded ...

The Manipulation of Narratives: Islam and the Modern World

 Mauritius, a nation with a relatively recent history of human habitation, serves as a reminder of how borders and civilizations are constructs shaped by the forces of history, often through colonial occupation. These borders, while scientifically and politically defined, have become sources of conflict, manipulated by those who wield power under the guise of nationalism. In this complex landscape, a troubling reality emerges: the purposeful creation of conflicts, where borders are used as tools to divide, and nationalism becomes a weapon to advance specific agendas. At the heart of this manipulation lies a broader, more insidious campaign that targets Islam.Throughout history, various ideologies—be they communist, imperialist, Zionist, or fascist—have played a role in this defamation.  Fascists, despite often coming to power through another religion or even under the guise of atheism or pseudo-non-religious ideologies, share a common goal: to distort and manipulate the image ...

Why the hatreds can't be stopped?

Disclaimer: No way to stop telling the truths,and we all know, seriously witnessing the atrocities against a human population only because they are different in beliefs. So it may trigger your dead brain and connect to heart. I think, start with some videos. The path to harmony can be built if Hindus act decently, truthfully and follow their religion without intruded hindutwa anti humane elements. India, a land of immense diversity, has long been home to numerous communities, cultures, and faiths, coexisting for centuries. However, in recent years, the rise of divisive politics has threatened this delicate balance. At the forefront of this polarization is the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (rss), an organization rooted in an ideology that some believe has sown seeds of hatred, exclusion, and discord. In 2024, the influence of this ideology has reached its zenith, with politics, media, and wealth seemingly intertwined to perpetuate a narrative that divides rather than unites. The concern i...